Top 5 Most Popular Pet Insurance Companies in the U.S. 2025

Pet insurance in the United States has seen rapid growth in recent years, and 2025 is no exception. With rising vet bills and more pet owners viewing animals as family, selecting the right insurance company has never been more important. Based on updated U.S. market data, user satisfaction, claims processing, and pricing structures, here are the top 5 most popular pet insurance companies in the U.S. for 2025—and how they stack up.

1. Healthy Paws Pet Insurance

Healthy Paws remains a crowd favorite, especially for its unlimited lifetime benefits and straightforward policy structure. The company consistently receives high marks for its lightning-fast claims reimbursements and excellent mobile app.

Founded: 2009
Coverage: Accidents, illnesses, hereditary & congenital conditions
Payout Cap: Unlimited
Reimbursement Options: 70%, 80%, 90%
Average Monthly Premium (Dog): $48
Waiting Period: 15 days

Why it’s popular in 2025:
Quick claim processing (average 2 days) and consistently high customer satisfaction ratings.

2. Spot Pet Insurance

Spot has climbed the ranks fast, thanks to its customizable plans and endorsement by celebrities like Cesar Millan. It’s especially popular among millennials seeking flexibility and a wellness option.

Founded: 2019
Coverage: Accidents, illnesses, preventive care (optional)
Payout Cap: Up to $10,000 or unlimited
Reimbursement Options: 70%, 80%, 90%
Average Monthly Premium (Dog): $44
Waiting Period: 14 days

Why it’s popular in 2025:
Highly flexible coverage levels and strong brand recognition among younger pet owners.

3. Fetch by The Dodo

Formerly Petplan, Fetch by The Dodo is known for its extensive coverage—including exam fees and holistic therapies. In 2025, its transparency and personalized quote system have made it a go-to for informed consumers.

Founded: 2003 (rebranded 2021)
Coverage: Accidents, illnesses, chronic conditions, exam fees
Payout Cap: $2,500 – Unlimited
Reimbursement Options: 70%, 80%, 90%
Average Monthly Premium (Dog): $52
Waiting Period: 15 days

Why it’s popular in 2025:
Detailed policies covering more than most competitors, including dental and alternative therapies.

4. Embrace Pet Insurance

Embrace has built a solid reputation for its wellness rewards program and diminishing deductible feature. Customers appreciate the added value beyond traditional accident & illness coverage.

Founded: 2003
Coverage: Accidents, illnesses, dental, behavioral therapy
Payout Cap: $5,000 – $30,000
Reimbursement Options: 70%, 80%, 90%
Average Monthly Premium (Dog): $49
Waiting Period: 14 days

Why it’s popular in 2025:
Extra perks like healthy pet deductibles and a growing library of educational content help it stand out.

5. Trupanion

Unlike most providers, Trupanion pays vets directly, removing the reimbursement waiting game. Though more expensive, its lifetime per-condition deductible and seamless claim system make it a trusted favorite in 2025.

Founded: 2000
Coverage: Accidents, illnesses, congenital conditions
Payout Cap: Unlimited
Reimbursement Options: Fixed at 90%
Average Monthly Premium (Dog): $70
Waiting Period: 5 days (accident), 30 days (illness)

Why it’s popular in 2025:
Real-time vet payments and high claim reliability win trust among long-term pet parents.

Pet Insurance Comparison Table (2025)

Company	Monthly Cost (Dog)	Max Payout	Reimbursement	Unique Features
Healthy Paws	$48	Unlimited	70-90%	Unlimited claims, mobile app, fast payments
Spot	$44	$10k or Unlimited	70-90%	Customizable plans, wellness options
Fetch by The Dodo	$52	Unlimited	70-90%	Covers exam fees, holistic care
Embrace	$49	$30,000	70-90%	Wellness add-on, diminishing deductible
Trupanion	$70	Unlimited	Fixed 90%	Direct vet payments, lifetime deductibles

FAQs About the Top Pet Insurance Companies

Q: Which pet insurance offers the fastest claims processing?
A: Healthy Paws is widely recognized for processing most claims within 2 days.

Q: Is Trupanion worth the higher premium?
A: For pet parents who prefer vet-direct payments and lifetime per-condition deductibles, Trupanion provides unmatched peace of mind.

Q: Can I get coverage for holistic treatments?
A: Yes, Fetch by The Dodo and Embrace both offer coverage for therapies like acupuncture or chiropractic care.

Q: Are there any companies with no annual limits?
A: Healthy Paws, Trupanion, and Fetch (with top-tier plans) all offer unlimited annual payouts.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right pet insurance in 2025 depends on what you value most: fast claims, flexible pricing, holistic care, or direct vet payments. Each of these five companies has carved out a niche by excelling in one or more of those areas. We recommend comparing quotes side-by-side based on your pet’s breed, age, and medical history.

Like this article? Share it with a fellow pet parent or leave a comment below about your experience with pet insurance.