Why Was My Pet Insurance Claim Denied?
“I paid for insurance, so why was my claim rejected?”
This is one of the most common questions pet owners ask after their pet becomes ill or injured. While pet insurance promises “comprehensive coverage,” in reality, many hidden clauses catch people off guard during the claims process.
This article analyzes the most common reasons for denied claims in 2025, based on the latest data and real cases from North America and Europe. We’ll also explain how to avoid these pitfalls so your furry friend receives the protection they deserve.
1. Congenital and Hereditary Conditions Are Often Excluded
Many pet insurance policies explicitly exclude congenital and hereditary diseases. For example, breeds like French Bulldogs or English Bulldogs, which are prone to respiratory issues, may be denied coverage if they fall ill—insurers often categorize such issues as “congenital airway defects.”
Real case: In March 2025, a French Bulldog owner named Amanda from New Jersey reported that her dog needed surgery due to an elongated soft palate. Her claim was denied on the grounds that “respiratory issues are hereditary.”
✅ Tip: Carefully check the exclusion clauses before purchasing, and pay attention to any breed-specific exclusions.
2. Pre-existing Conditions Before Enrollment Are Not Covered
This is one of the most frequent reasons for claim denials. Insurance companies will investigate your pet’s medical history prior to enrollment. Even minor symptoms may be classified as a pre-existing condition.
Real case: A British Shorthair cat was hospitalized in early 2025 for a urinary issue. The owner had just purchased insurance in late 2024. Although the condition worsened after coverage began, the claim was denied because the pet had seen a vet for similar symptoms prior to enrollment.
✅ Tip: If your pet has a medical history, find out whether the policy includes waiting periods or waivers for pre-existing conditions.
3. Missed Vaccinations May Be Seen as Owner Negligence
If your pet contracts a disease for which a vaccine exists, and they weren’t vaccinated in time, the insurer may argue that you were negligent and reject the claim.
Common vaccines include:
- Dogs: Rabies, Canine Distemper, Parvovirus
- Cats: Feline Panleukopenia, Feline Herpesvirus, Calicivirus
✅ Tip: Keep a complete and updated vaccination record. Regular check-ups can prevent denials based on “preventive care negligence.”
4. Illnesses Occurring During the Waiting Period Are Not Covered
Most pet insurance policies include a waiting period, usually 14 to 30 days from the start of coverage. Any illnesses or injuries during this time are not eligible for reimbursement.
Example: You purchase insurance on January 1. Your pet develops an ear infection on January 10. The claim is likely to be denied for falling within the waiting period.
✅ Tip: Avoid signing up when your pet is already showing symptoms. Plan insurance coverage early.
5. Treatments from Unapproved Providers May Be Denied
Some insurers require that treatment be performed by licensed veterinarians or within their preferred provider network. If you go to an unlisted clinic, even valid treatments may not be reimbursed.
✅ Tip: Verify your insurer’s approved care providers and save all prescriptions, test results, and payment records.
6. “Non-essential” or Unrelated Treatments May Be Excluded
Even if a vet prescribes a treatment, insurers may reject it if they determine it’s not medically necessary or unrelated to the primary diagnosis.
Real case: In 2025, a Canadian pet owner took their dog for a dental cleaning and also treated inflamed gums during the visit. The dental cleaning was denied because the insurer classified it as “routine care,” not illness-related treatment.
✅ Tip: Make sure all treatments are clearly documented as medically necessary and directly related to the illness.
7. Late Filing or Incomplete Documentation
Many policies require claims to be submitted within a set number of days after treatment. Missing the deadline or providing incomplete documents can lead to automatic denial.
✅ Tip: Photograph and save all receipts and records immediately after treatment. Use the insurer’s app or website to submit claims promptly.
8. Breed Restrictions and Senior Pet Limitations
Some high-risk breeds are excluded entirely or receive only limited coverage. For senior pets (often 10 years or older), premiums may be high, deductibles steep, and reimbursement difficult to obtain.
How to Improve Your Claim Approval Rate?
According to 2025 data from the U.S., Canada, and the U.K., the top 3 reasons for pet insurance claim denials are:
- Pre-existing conditions before enrollment (38%)
- Missing vaccinations or poor preventive care (24%)
- Claims submitted during the waiting period (17%)
✅ Checklist Before Buying Insurance:
- Read the full policy, including all fine print and exclusions
- Ask your insurer: Are hereditary conditions covered? What’s the waiting period? Are minor prior illnesses excluded?
- Keep thorough health and vaccination records
- Choose insurers with a good reputation for claim approvals (e.g., Trupanion, Healthy Paws, Petplan)
If you want to ensure your claims are accepted, consider regularly reviewing your policy and comparing products from different insurers to choose the one best suited for your pet’s breed, age, and health profile.
FAQ: Pet Insurance Claims
Q1: What’s considered a pre-existing condition in pet insurance?
A1: Any illness, injury, or symptom that occurred or was noticed before your policy’s start date. Even if it wasn’t officially diagnosed, it can still be considered pre-existing.
Q2: How long is the typical waiting period for pet insurance?
A2: Usually 14 days for illnesses, and 48-72 hours for accidents. Some conditions, like orthopedic issues, may have a 6-month waiting period.
Q3: Can dental cleanings or vaccines be claimed under pet insurance?
A3: Only if you purchased a wellness add-on. Basic accident/illness plans typically don’t cover preventive care like cleanings or vaccinations.
Q4: What happens if I submit a claim late?
A4: Most insurers give you 60–90 days to submit a claim. Missing the deadline usually results in automatic denial.
Q5: Are there any 2025 pet insurance plans with fewer exclusions?
A5: Yes. In 2025, top-rated providers like Healthy Paws, Trupanion, and Fetch have simplified plans with broader coverage, though they may cost more. Always compare plans and read customer reviews.
Have you ever had a pet insurance claim denied? Share your story and tips in the comments below!
How to Choose the Best Value Pet Insurance Plan in 2025
